When you're building a PlayStation 5 library, two very different current generation video games often compete for the same budget: The Last of Us Part I and Mortal Kombat Legacy Kollection. One is a heavily narrative-driven action adventure rebuilt for PS5; the other is a fighting-oriented collection priced lower. The choice comes down to how you want to play.
Quick verdict: If you want a cinematic, emotional single-player story, choose The Last of Us Part I. If you'd rather have fast-paced martial-arts combat on PS5 for less, choose Mortal Kombat Legacy Kollection.
| Game | Price | Price Bar | Condition | Genre | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Last of Us Part I | $27.99 | Brand New | Action \& Adventure | Solo story campaign | |
| Mortal Kombat Legacy Kollection | $24.49 | Like New (New and Unplayed) | Fighting, Action / Adventure | Quick matches and combo play |
Where The Last of Us Part I wins: This is the pick for players who value narrative depth. It includes the complete single-player story plus the Left Behind prequel chapter, which explores events that changed Ellie and her best friend Riley. The PS5 rebuild brings more realistic lighting, intricate environments, and a creative reimagining of familiar spaces. It supports one player, so it's an intensely personal experience. The $27.99 price is $3.50 more than the fighting game, but you're paying for a campaign meant to be savored rather than a quick session.
Where Mortal Kombat Legacy Kollection wins: If your PS5 time is about short, replayable bursts of action, this is the lower-cost option at $24.49. It's described as Like New and New and Unplayed, which makes it an attractive buy despite not being sealed. Its genre mix of Fighting and Action / Adventure points to a game built around combat challenges rather than a linear story. The $3.50 savings might matter if you're on a tight budget or already have a long RPG queued up. It's the smarter choice for players who prioritize gameplay loops over story beats.
The Last of Us Part I
The Last of Us Part I is a PS5 adaptation of the game that launched the series. The full single-player story is here, and the included Left Behind prequel adds depth to Ellie's past. The visual overhaul described for this version makes environments feel more lived-in, with lighting and atmosphere designed to pull you into the grim journey. It's a one-player experience, so it suits someone who wants to get lost in a character-driven adventure without interruptions. At $27.99, it's the higher-priced option, but it offers a complete emotional arc and a polished PS5 presentation. If you care about storytelling and atmospheric exploration, this is the game to fill that need.
Mortal Kombat Legacy Kollection
Mortal Kombat Legacy Kollection sits at $24.49, making it the more budget-conscious PS5 purchase here. The condition is Like New, but the feature notes say New and Unplayed, so you get a clean copy without the full retail markup. Its genre classification as Fighting and Action / Adventure means the core draw is combat: quick matches, special moves, and the challenge of mastering a fighter. There is no mention of a story-heavy campaign or prequel chapter, so this is better suited to players who want to jump into matches rather than follow a narrative. The $3.50 price difference adds up if you also plan to buy a second game, and the fighting focus gives it strong repeat-play value.
Final choice by use case: Pick The Last of Us Part I if you want a story-rich, single-player action adventure with cinematic presentation and a built-in prequel. Pick Mortal Kombat Legacy Kollection if you want a lower-priced fighting game with quick, replayable combat and are comfortable with a Like New copy that still counts as New and Unplayed.
