Two of PlayStation 5's biggest story-driven releases are sitting right next to each other on store shelves, and they cost almost the same. The Last of Us Part I is a tense, emotional journey through a collapsed world. Marvel's Spider-Man 2 is a bright, high-speed superhero playground. If you only have room in your collection for one current generation video game right now, the decision comes down to what you want out of your next session.
Quick Verdict
Go with The Last of Us Part I for a more intense, narrative-first experience. Choose Marvel's Spider-Man 2 for a more carefree, action-packed open-world adventure. Both are solid PS5 purchases, but they serve different moods.
At a Glance
| Game | Listed Price | Price Bar | ESRB Rating | Playable Cast | Best For |
| The Last of Us Part I | $27.99 | | Mature 17+ | Joel and Ellie | Emotional, linear story |
| Marvel's Spider-Man 2 | $25.99 | | Teen | Peter Parker and Miles Morales | Open-world superhero action |
Both games are built for PS5, so you're getting a current generation experience either way. The real decision is whether you want a linear, story-first journey or a high-energy action-adventure.
Where Each Product Wins
- The Last of Us Part I wins on story depth and atmosphere. The PS5 version rebuilds the original adventure with enhanced visuals and more realistic lighting. If you want a slower burn that rewards patience, this is the one.
- Marvel's Spider-Man 2 wins on variety and momentum. You get two playable heroes, Web Wings for faster traversal, and a roster of villains including Venom, Kraven, and Lizard. If you want to feel powerful and keep moving, this is the one.
The Last of Us Part I
The PS5 version rebuilds the original adventure with enhanced visuals and more realistic lighting, making the post-outbreak world feel more oppressive. The complete single-player campaign is here, and it includes Left Behind, the prequel chapter that tells Ellie and Riley's story. It's rated Mature 17+ and supports one player, so it's a deeply personal, solo experience. The emotional core is strong, but the pacing is deliberate and the stealth combat can be tense. If you're looking for something relaxing or family-friendly, this isn't it. But if you want a game that stays with you after the credits, this is the one.
Marvel's Spider-Man 2
Marvel's Spider-Man 2 is an open-world action game that lets you play as both Peter Parker and Miles Morales, with the ability to switch between them on the fly. The new Web Wings allow for fast, fluid traversal across an expanded Marvel's New York, and you'll face off against Venom, Kraven the Hunter, and Lizard. It's rated Teen, includes in-game purchases, and has DLC available. The DualSense adaptive triggers and haptic feedback make every swing and punch feel more tactile. The story is lighter than The Last of Us Part I, and the open-world collection tasks can distract from the main plot. If you want a more playful, high-energy superhero experience, this is the one.
Final Choice by Use Case
At the listed prices, Marvel's Spider-Man 2 is $2 cheaper at $25.99, and it gives you a bigger open world, two heroes, and more room to roam. The Last of Us Part I costs $27.99, $2 more, but it delivers a more emotional, linear story and includes the complete story plus the beloved prequel chapter. For a family-friendly or casual gaming night, pick Marvel's Spider-Man 2. For a solo evening with a powerful narrative, pick The Last of Us Part I.
