SNES Classic, GameCube, or 3DS XL: Which Console Handheld Hardware Should You Pick?

Choosing console handheld hardware is deceptively hard. One machine gives you a ready library; another asks you to supply games and memory cards; a third is something that fits in a pocket. The four options here range from $78.95 to $154, a spread of about $75.05, which means budget alone won't decide it. You also need to decide whether you want to play on a TV or on the go.

Quick take

If you just want to start playing fast, the SNES Classic Edition is a console that comes ready to play. The Classic Edition US Mini Game is the lowest-priced choice in this group. The GameCube DOL-001 is the classic home console in the group. The 3DS XL is the only true handheld here.

Listed price comparison

Decision matrix

Match your priority to a machine:

• If you want a living-room two-player machine with a preloaded 16-bit library, the SNES Classic Edition fits.
• If you want the lowest listed price in this group and a fixed NES library, the Classic Edition US Mini Game is the straightforward pick.
• If you want to play physical GameCube discs and want a range of analog video connections, the GameCube DOL-001 is the one.
• If you want a portable system, the 3DS XL is your match.

Product notes

NEW For Nintendo SNES Classic Edition Mini Super Entertainment System

The SNES Classic Edition is a direct path to 16-bit Nintendo play. It arrives new and includes two wired controllers, an HDMI cable, a USB power cable, a manual, and a retail box, so you can connect it to a modern TV and start playing almost immediately. The Model Super NES Classic Edition name and the Region Free designation make it an approachable choice. If you only need one console for solo sessions, you may not need the extra controller or the higher price relative to the mini NES-style option. It relies on HDMI for video output.

Classic Edition US Mini Game

This mini console is built around a fixed 30-game NES library that includes Super Mario Bros., The Legend of Zelda, PAC-MAN, Metroid, and Mega Man 2. The package includes one controller, a cable set, a manual, a poster, and a compatible wall charger. That charger is a useful extra, since some mini consoles require you to supply one separately. The single controller is the real limitation: the box only covers one player out of the gate. The 3-month manufacturer warranty adds a little peace of mind for a small dedicated retro machine.

Nintendo GameCube Console DOL-001 (NTSC-U/C US/Canada)

The GameCube DOL-001 is a pre-owned/refurbished home console for people who want to play physical discs. The unit is in very good refurbished condition, has a 1-year manufacturer warranty, and offers connectivity options that stand out: component RCA, S-Video, and VGA. That gives you flexibility with different displays. The practical limitations are visible: memory card not included, bottom panel covers may be missing, and the AV cable may be a generic replacement rather than an official Nintendo cable. The console, controller, and AC adapter are authentic Nintendo products, but you should plan for those cosmetic and accessory caveats.

Nintendo 3DS XL with 16GB SD Card

The 3DS XL is the only handheld in this group. The unit is red, used, and in VG condition, meaning a clean shell with minor or no scratches. A charger and a 16GB SD card are included, so you can add games without buying storage right away. The Region Free designation matters if you want to play titles from different regions. The biggest limitation is that these systems generally don't have access to Nintendo Services or the eShop, so you should treat it as a physical-cartridge handheld. The used-condition caveats are also something to keep in mind.

Final recommendation by use case

• Living-room two-player retro play: SNES Classic Edition.
• The all-in-one console: Classic Edition US Mini Game.
• For GameCube fans: GameCube DOL-001.
• Take-it-anywhere play with included storage: 3DS XL.