If you're staring at two very different strategy guides-one for a sprawling modern Western, one for a classic PlayStation adventure-the decision isn't about which book is "better." It's about which game you're playing, what condition you're comfortable with, and how you want to experience the walkthrough.
Quick verdict
For most players, the Red Dead Redemption 2 Ultimate Game Guide is the smarter pick. It's a brand-new paperback with full walkthrough coverage, and it costs $30.25. The Tomb Raider 3 PS1 Strategy Guide earns its place if you specifically want the official PS1-era guidebook for Tomb Raider 3 and are okay paying $81.20 for a used copy in good condition.
Comparison at a glance
| Aspect | Red Dead Redemption 2 Ultimate Game Guide | Tomb Raider 3 PS1 Strategy Guide |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $30.25 | $81.20 |
| Condition | Brand New | Good |
| Format | Paperback | Guidebook |
| Focus | Full RDR2 walkthrough and tips | Official Tomb Raider 3 PS1 walkthrough |
Where each guide wins
Red Dead Redemption 2 Ultimate Game Guide wins if you want:
- A brand-new paperback with no visible wear.
- A complete walkthrough that covers missions and hidden secrets.
- A guide written for a modern open-world game.
Tomb Raider 3 PS1 Strategy Guide wins if you want:
- The official strategy guide for the original PlayStation Tomb Raider 3.
- A used guidebook with the look and feel of the PS1 era.
- A dedicated companion for retro gameplay.
Product notes
Red Dead Redemption 2 Ultimate Game Guide
This paperback guide, written by Ivan Parker, is a brand-new companion for Rockstar's Red Dead Redemption 2. It's designed to help you work through the full story, find side activities, and uncover the secrets scattered across the open world. If you're starting a fresh playthrough and want an unscuffed book you can stash next to your controller, this is the cleaner, more convenient option. The main limitation is scope: it's built for Red Dead Redemption 2 only, so it won't help you with other games or older titles like Tomb Raider 3. The condition alone makes it a sensible choice for anyone who prefers crisp pages and no wear over a collector's item.
Tomb Raider 3 PS1 Strategy Guide
This is the official guidebook for Tomb Raider 3 on the original PlayStation, and it's being sold as a used item in good condition. If you're replaying Lara Croft's third adventure and want the same book that players used in that era, this guide matches that specific need. The title identifies it clearly as the official walkthrough, so you know exactly what you're getting before you commit. The trade-offs are the used condition and the fact that it's an older guidebook rather than a fresh paperback. It's the right pick for a Tomb Raider fan who wants the authentic PS1 companion.
Final choice by use case
Choose the Red Dead Redemption 2 Ultimate Game Guide when you want a fresh, complete walkthrough for a modern game and prefer a book in brand-new condition.
Choose the Tomb Raider 3 PS1 Strategy Guide when you're a retro PlayStation player or collector who needs the official PS1 guidebook and is willing to buy it used.
