Choosing between these two collector limited editions puts very different gaming eras side by side. On one hand, you have a pre-sale PlayStation 5 survival-horror collector's edition built around Michael Myers; on the other, a sealed, E-rated Game Boy Color action-adventure from the Limited Run Games and Crunchyroll partnership. The practical decision comes down to how much display space and budget you want to commit, and whether you collect for current consoles or retro handhelds.
Quick Verdict
If you want a current-gen horror showpiece and have $249.99 set aside, the Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition for PS5 is the one. If you'd rather spend $55.00 on a sealed retro cart with an approachable rating, Hime's Quest is the pick.
Comparison Table
| Consideration | Halloween The Game PS5 Collector's Edition | Hime's Quest Sealed GBC |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $249.99 | $55.00 |
| Platform | Sony PlayStation 5 | Nintendo Game Boy Color |
| Genre | Survival Horror | Action & Adventure |
| Rating | Rating Pending | E for Everyone |
| Publisher | Sony | Nintendo |
| Edition focus | Collector's Edition | Sealed Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll |
| Condition | Brand New | Brand New |
Where Each Product Wins
For the current-console collector, Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition PS5 is the obvious pick. It's a pre-sale collector's edition with the Michael Myers name attached, a survival-horror genre fit, and a Rating Pending notice that keeps the mystery intact. If you have a PS5 and want the game as the centerpiece of a horror display, this is your route.
For the retro collector, Hime's Quest is the better fit. It's an E-rated action-adventure game for Nintendo Game Boy Color, published by Nintendo, and it comes sealed in its Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll edition. The lower price leaves room to add other pieces, and the format is much easier to store.
Product Notes
Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition PS5
This pre-sale collector's edition is the higher-priced option in this head-to-head. It's built for the Sony PlayStation 5, drops into the survival horror space, and carries the Michael Myers branding from the Halloween series. The rating is still pending, which is common for a title slated for a 2026 release. If your collection leans toward big modern boxes and you want a horror centerpiece with a PS5 future, this is the one to reserve. The main limitation is the investment and the format: you're paying a significant amount for a pre-sale, and the game isn't out yet. You'll also need a PS5 to play it, so it's not the choice for someone without current-gen hardware.
Hime's Quest Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll, Sealed Edition
Hime's Quest is the lower-price pick, but it brings its own collector appeal. It's a sealed US edition for Nintendo Game Boy Color from the Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll collaboration, with an E rating and an action-and-adventure style. The sealed condition makes it attractive to retro collectors, and Nintendo is the listed publisher. That said, both available copies have cosmetic flaws, so you'll choose which one you're buying. It's also a Game Boy Color game, so you'll need original hardware or a compatible system to play it. If you're after a compact, relatively easy-to-store collectible and don't need modern graphics, this one is worth considering.
Final Choice by Use Case
If you're a horror fan who wants a bold PS5 collector's edition to anchor a shelf, choose Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition PS5 and commit to the higher spend. If you're a retro-focused collector who wants a sealed, E-rated Game Boy Color cart that costs far less and takes up less space, choose Hime's Quest Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll sealed edition. The real deciding factor is whether your collection is headed toward current-gen horror or handheld nostalgia.
