Choosing between two collector limited editions usually comes down to what you want on your shelf: a modern, licensed centerpiece or a piece of handheld history. That's exactly the choice here. Halloween The Game PS5 edition brings Michael Myers to current-gen gaming, while Hime's Quest is a Game Boy Color action-adventure. Both are brand new with US origin, but they serve completely different collecting instincts.
Quick Verdict
If your collection needs a survival-horror showpiece on PlayStation 5, the Halloween The Game PS5 edition is the stronger pick. At USD 249.98, it carries an RP rating pending and the built-in appeal of the Halloween name. If you'd rather spend much less and add a retro cartridge to your shelf, Hime's Quest is the lower-commitment option with a Game Boy Color action-adventure pedigree. The USD 194.98 gap between them makes the buying decision feel less like a comparison and more like a question of which kind of collector you are.
Comparison
| Product | Price | Price Bar | Platform | Genre | Condition | Notable Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition | USD 249.98 | PlayStation 5 | Survival Horror | Brand New | Collector's Edition; Michael Myers; RP Rating Pending; 2026 | |
| Hime's Quest Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll Sealed Edition | USD 55.00 | Game Boy Color | Action & Adventure | Brand New | Sealed; E-Everyone; NTSC-U/C; Limited Run x Crunchyroll |
Where Each Product Wins
- Halloween The Game PS5 edition wins for PS5 collectors who want a licensed horror icon as the focal point. It's the more substantial display piece, and the survival-horror genre fits the collection theme well.
- Hime's Quest Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll Sealed Edition wins for retro enthusiasts who value the cartridge format and a collaboration with a distinct identity. It's also the lower-priced route into this particular head-to-head.
Product Notes
Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition (PS5)
If you want your collection to make a bold statement, this PS5 edition is the one that delivers. The name alone ties it to Michael Myers, and the Collector's Edition label means this isn't a plain retail copy. It's brand new and built for survival-horror fans on Sony's platform. The rating is still pending, and it's a presale, so you're committing ahead of the 2026 release. That's the main limitation: you're paying at the upper end of the price spread before the release arrives. If you already know you want the current-gen horror showpiece, this is the edition to lock in.
Hime's Quest Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll Sealed Edition
For the retro-leaning collector, Hime's Quest is the more curiosity-driven pick. It comes from the Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll line, and the sealed presentation gives it a very different collecting vibe from a PS5 display piece. The game is action-and-adventure, rated E-Everyone, and carries an NTSC-U/C region code, so it fits a North American handheld collection cleanly. The practical limitation is the condition caveat: both units have cosmetic flaws, and you pick between them. That means the sealed wrapper may not be perfect. Still, as the lower-priced side of this comparison, it's an easy way to add a Nintendo-era rarity to your shelf.
Final Choice by Use Case
Choose Halloween The Game PS5 edition if you collect PS5 survival-horror games and want a licensed horror centerpiece, even at the higher price. Choose Hime's Quest Limited Run Games x Crunchyroll Sealed Edition if you prefer a Game Boy Color cart from a limited collaboration and can accept a little cosmetic imperfection. Both are brand-new US-origin editions, but one is a modern trophy and the other is a retro rarity.
