Two PS5 collector limited editions, two very different ways to build a shelf: one is a brand-new limited horror-game presale featuring Michael Myers, and the other is a complete Saints Row Notorious Collector's Edition bundle. Nearly a $162 price gap separates them, so the decision is really about what kind of collector you are.
Quick Verdict
Go with the Saints Row Notorious Collector's Edition if you want a full, playable PS5 bundle for a much lower outlay. Choose the Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition if you're after a horror showpiece and are willing to wait for the release and pay more for a new limited edition.
At a Glance
| Product | Listed Price | Price Bar | Condition | Genre | Edition Highlights |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition (PS5) | $249.99 | Brand New | Survival Horror | Limited Collector's Edition | |
| Saints Row Notorious Collector's Edition & Santo Ileso Pack (PS5) | $88.28 | Very Good | Action & Adventure | Notorious Edition, SteelBook Edition, Collector's Edition |
Where Each Product Wins
Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition wins if you want a distinct horror identity in your collection and a more dramatic display piece. The Michael Myers theme and the limited-edition framing give it a clear collector's hook.
Saints Row Notorious Collector's Edition wins if you want the complete package now: the over-the-top campaign, the extra cards, and multiple collector's extras from Deep Silver. It's the easier recommendation for someone who wants to actually play a full game without waiting.
Product Notes
PRESALE Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition (PS5)
This is the choice for someone who wants a limited survival-horror centerpiece and is comfortable waiting for it. The edition is brand new, the PS5 game is scheduled for a 2026 release, and the whole presentation is built around Michael Myers. That theme gives it a strong collector's identity, especially if you're a Halloween series fan. The trade-off is the $249.99 price, the highest in this comparison, and the fact that it is a presale: you're reserving something that hasn't been released yet rather than buying a ready-to-play game. If you want the drama of a true limited horror edition on your shelf, this one delivers a bigger visual story. If you want immediate entertainment, though, the wait undercuts the appeal.
Saints Row Notorious Collector's Edition (PS5)
This set suits the collector who wants more content for a lower price. It's in Very Good condition and includes the Notorious Edition, the SteelBook Edition, and the Santo Ileso Pack, with art cards and character cards still in their bands from the original bundle. At $88.28, it gives you a complete Saints Row action-adventure experience from Deep Silver for less than the Halloween presale. The limitation is the condition: this is not a brand-new sealed edition, so the outer presentation won't have that just-unboxed feel. It's also rooted in Saints Row's absurd, boundary-pushing humor rather than horror. If you'd rather play a full game with steelbook packaging and extra cards, this is the more immediate pick.
Final Choice by Use Case
If you're buying for display and collectibility: Halloween The Game Limited Collector's Edition is the bigger statement. The limited horror edition and the Michael Myers theme are the main draw, and the 2026 wait is acceptable.
If you're buying for gameplay and a complete package: Saints Row Notorious Collector's Edition is the smarter buy. You get a full game and collector's extras at a much lower price.
