When you're shopping for current generation video games, the Rockstar Games section can stop you in your tracks. Two brand-new titles sit side by side: Grand Theft Auto V for PlayStation 5 and Red Dead Redemption for Nintendo Switch. You're looking at two different consoles, two different play experiences, and two different price points. The decision isn't about which game is better-it's about which one fits the hardware you own and the budget you're working with. Both are published by Rockstar Games, but one is built for Sony's PS5 and the other for Nintendo's Switch, so your console already narrows the field. Your console choice alone may settle this, but if you own both, the price and genre details are where the differences show up.
Quick Verdict
If you own a PlayStation 5 and want the lower-cost pick, go with Grand Theft Auto V (PS5). If you own a Nintendo Switch and want an action-adventure from Rockstar, go with Red Dead Redemption. Both are brand new, so you're choosing between a PS5 version and a Switch version based on platform fit first and price second. For the budget-minded PS5 owner, GTA V is the clear save. For the Switch owner who wants a Rockstar title in the action-adventure genre, Red Dead is the one.
At a Glance
| Game | Platform | Price | Condition | Notable Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rockstar Games Grand Theft Auto V (PS5) | PlayStation 5 | USD 16.00 | Brand New | Published by Rockstar Games |
| Rockstar Games Presents Red Dead Redemption Nintendo Switch Game | Nintendo Switch | USD 29.99 | Brand New | Action & Adventure; Rated M |
The prices sit $13.99 apart, with the PS5 version at the lower end. Both are in brand-new condition, so the condition isn't a deciding factor between them. The price spread is the main financial difference, and the genre detail is the main gameplay difference.
Where Each Product Wins
Grand Theft Auto V (PS5) wins when your console is a PlayStation 5 and you want the more affordable of the two. It's a brand-new copy published by Rockstar Games. If you're watching your spending and you already have a PS5, this is the pick.
Red Dead Redemption (Nintendo Switch) wins when your console is a Nintendo Switch and you want an action-adventure title from Rockstar. This one carries an M rating and is brand new, and it's aimed at a more mature audience. The Switch platform and the action-adventure genre make it the choice for Switch owners.
Product Notes
Grand Theft Auto V (PS5)
This PS5 version is the more affordable of the two, sitting at the lower end of the price range. It's a brand-new copy, so you're getting a fresh PS5 game without spending extra, and there's no wear-and-tear to worry about. If you already have a PlayStation 5, this is the more budget-friendly Rockstar title in this matchup. The main limitation is the platform: it's designed for PS5, so it won't help if you're playing on a Nintendo Switch. For a PS5 owner who wants a Rockstar game at a smaller outlay, this is the choice to make. The condition is brand new, and the publisher is Rockstar Games, so there's no mystery about what you're buying.
Red Dead Redemption (Nintendo Switch)
The Nintendo Switch version of Red Dead Redemption is the higher-priced of the two, but it brings the action-adventure genre to your Switch. It arrives factory sealed as a brand-new game and is compatible with the Switch Pro Controller, so it fits nicely into a Switch library, and the Pro Controller support is a nice extra if you play on the TV. The Mature rating means it's aimed at adult players, and the country of origin is Japan. The limitation is the price point: it costs more than the PS5 option, so you're paying more for the Switch platform. If you're on a Nintendo Switch and want a Rockstar action-adventure, this is the one to pick.
Final Choice by Use Case
If you play on PlayStation 5 and want the lower-cost Rockstar game, Grand Theft Auto V is the pick. If you play on Nintendo Switch and want an action-adventure with a Mature rating, Red Dead Redemption is the pick. For owners of both consoles, the decision comes down to whether you're willing to spend more for the Switch version or save with the PS5 version.
