You're deciding between two mature-rated action-adventure games for a current-generation console, and both are tempting. One delivers a complete paranormal adventure on PlayStation 5, with a story about a corruptive presence invading the Federal Bureau of Control. The other is a single-player western saga on Nintendo Switch, presented by Rockstar Games. The $7 price gap between them might be the smallest part of the difference. Your choice comes down to which console you own and whether you prefer a fuller package or a portable story. Here's how to pick.
Quick Verdict
If you want the full package, Control: Ultimate Edition is the one to get. If you want a story-driven western on Switch, Red Dead Redemption is the flexible option.
At a Glance
| Game | Platform | Price | Condition | Genre |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Control: Ultimate Edition | Sony PlayStation 5 | USD 36.99 | Brand New | Action & Adventure |
| Rockstar Games Presents Red Dead Redemption | Nintendo Switch | USD 29.99 | Brand New | Action & Adventure |
Both games are listed as brand new, and both share the action-adventure genre and mature rating. The platform difference is clear, and the packaged content is where they diverge. Think of it this way: Control gives you a bigger collection of content, while Red Dead Redemption gives you a ready-to-play story on a portable console.
Where Each Product Wins
- Control: Ultimate Edition wins when you want the base game and both expansions (The Foundation and AWE) in one place, so you don't need to track down extra content later.
- Red Dead Redemption on Switch wins when you value portability and a straightforward single-player campaign, with Switch Pro Controller support for docked sessions.
Product Notes
Control: Ultimate Edition - PlayStation 5 Classic Game
The Ultimate Edition of Control gathers the main game and both expansions, so the full story is ready from the moment you start. On PS5, it takes advantage of 4K graphics, ray-tracing, and a 60fps Performance mode, making the supernatural battles at the Federal Bureau of Control feel fluid and visually striking. The story follows an invasion by a corruptive presence, and your character uses the environment as a weapon in unpredictable settings. At USD 36.99, it's the higher-priced choice, and it's for the PlayStation 5. It carries a mature rating and an action-adventure genre label, just like the Switch game, but the bundled expansions are what make this a complete, single-purchase package. If you own a PS5 and want a polished adventure without tracking down extra downloads, this is the option that gives you everything from the start.
Rockstar Games Presents Red Dead Redemption Nintendo Switch Game
At USD 29.99, this Switch release is the lower-priced of the two, and it arrives as a brand-new, factory-sealed copy. It features a single-player campaign and supports the Switch Pro Controller, so you can play handheld or docked comfortably. The mature-rated story is presented by Rockstar Games, and the western action-adventure experience is the focus. For players who want a story-driven adventure without the need for expansions, this is a focused purchase. If you prefer a bundle with extra expansions and enhanced console graphics, the Control Ultimate Edition on PS5 is the route to take. For a straight, portable western adventure at a lower price, Red Dead Redemption on Switch is a solid fit.
Final Choice by Use Case
If you own a PlayStation 5 and want the most complete version of Control, with its expansions and enhanced graphics, choose the Ultimate Edition. If you're on Switch, pick up Red Dead Redemption.
