Two big-box PC games from the physical-media era are in front of you, and they pull collectors in opposite directions. One is a sealed horror sequel with a lofty price tag. The other is a complete space adventure with a more accessible listed price and a map that shows real play wear. Which is the better pick for your shelf depends on whether you value pristine shrink-wrap or original completeness with verified-readable floppies.
Quick Verdict
If you want a sealed centerpiece and can pay the higher end of the range, Blood II: The Chosen is the choice. If you prefer a full box with manual, map, paperwork, and readable disks at a lower listed price, Star Control II is the buy.
At a Glance
| Product | Listed Price | Price Bar | Key Attribute |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blood II: The Chosen PC Big Box - Brand New & Mint | USD 249.95 | Brand new | |
| Star Control II PC Big Box - 3.5-inch Floppy Complete | USD 119.99 | Readable disks |
Where Blood II Wins
Blood II: The Chosen is described as brand new, factory wrapped, and mint. For collectors who care about a sealed presentation, that's a significant advantage: you're getting the 1998 big box without shelf wear, dents, or missing shrink-wrap. Packing details include new boxes, bubble wrap, and bubble bags from a smoke-free home. It's the higher listed price of the two, so you're paying for that untouched state.
Where Star Control II Wins
Star Control II is the more complete set on paper. The set includes the original big box, four original floppy disks, the original star map, manuals, registration/warranty paperwork, and original inserts. The disks were read-tested successfully: all four read with zero file copy failures. That's a meaningful benefit for a game this old, because floppies are the fragile part of the set. It also carries the lower listed price, $119.99.
Product Notes
Blood II: The Chosen PC Big Box - Brand New & Mint
This is the centerpiece option for anyone who prioritizes untouched box condition. It's presented as a factory-wrapped, mint 1998 release, and the $249.95 listed price reflects that sealed state. Packing details also align with the condition focus: new boxes, bubble wrap, and bubble bags from a smoke-free home. The trade-off is that you're at the higher end of the price range, and the value rests on that pristine sealed box rather than a bundled extras list. If a flawless big-box shell is your goal, this is the one. That makes it a strong candidate for a display shelf rather than a player's copy.
Star Control II PC Big Box - 3.5-inch Floppy Complete
If completeness and media survival matter more than shrink-wrap, this set is hard to beat in the lineup. It includes the original big box, four original 3.5-inch floppy disks, an original star map, manuals, registration/warranty paperwork, and original inserts. The disks were all read successfully with zero file copy failures, giving you confidence in the floppies. The condition is Good, so there is visible shelf wear, and the map has tape removal and small pinholes from early use. At $119.99, it's the lower listed price, but it is a used item with honest wear.
Final Choice by Use Case
Choose Blood II: The Chosen if you're after a factory-wrapped, mint-condition big box and the higher listed price sits within your budget. Choose Star Control II if you want a complete original set with readable disks and the original map, and you're comfortable with Good condition wear.
